XU Pei-rong, HUANG Jia-qi, ZHANG Si-hong, XIANG Zhuo-yi, LI Yao-hui, HE Min-ke, ZHU Yan-jun, GUO Jian-ming, WANG Hang
Objective To assess the application of renal tumor complexity assessment systems in preoperatively predicting WHO/ISUP nuclear grade of clear-cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC). Methods Between Jan 2017 and Dec 2019,1 272 ccRCC patients diagnosed by postoperative pathology in Zhongshan Hospital,Fudan University,including 867 males and 405 females were analyzed retrospectively.The age ranged from 19 to 86 years,with an average of 58 years.The tumors in left and right kidney were observed in 614 and 658 cases,respectively.Renal tumor complexity was quantified using the RENAL score,PADUA score,and Zhongshan score.The histological nuclear grade was assessed by WHO/ISUP classification.WHO/ISUP grade Ⅰand Ⅱ were classified as low grade,and WHO/ISUP grade Ⅲ and Ⅳ were classified as high grade. Results All the 1 272 patients underwent surgery successfully,including 766 nephron-sparing surgery and 506 radical nephrectomy.Open surgery,traditional laparoscopic surgery and robot-assisted laparoscopic surgery were performed in 536,433 and 303 patients,respectively.According to WHO/ISUP classification,there were 62 patients in grade Ⅰ,963 patients in grade Ⅱ,219 patients in grade Ⅲ,and 28 patients in grade Ⅳ.In the RENAL score,the proportions of high WHO/ISUP grade in low,medium and high complexity tumor were 4.0% (11/273),16.3% (94/576) and 33.6%(142/423),respectively.In PADUA score,the proportions of high WHO/ISUP grade in low,medium and high complexity tumor were 2.6% (5/196),8.3%(21/254) and 26.9%(221/822),respectively.In Zhongshan score,the proportion of high WHO/ISUP grade in low,medium and high complexity tumor was 0.9% (1/109),6.4% (23/362)and 27.8% (223/801),respectively.In all the three score systems,the proportions of high WHO/ISUP nuclear grades in low,medium and high complexity tumor were significantly different (P<0.001).However,there was no difference among the three score systems (P=0.102).In addition,WHO/ISUP Ⅲ-Ⅳ accounted for more than 50% of tumors with RENAL score >10 and PADUA score >12.Tumors with Zhongshan score >14 were all WHO/ISUP Ⅲ-Ⅳ. Conclusion There is a positive correlation between tumor complexity of ccRCC and WHO/ISUP nuclear grade.The combined application of RENAL score,PADUA score and Zhongshan score can better preoperatively predict WHO/ISUP nuclear grade of ccRCC.